Hot Tub Vacuum vs Skimmer Net: Which One Should You Buy?

Hot tub vacuum vs skimmer net at a glance

How each side cleans

A vacuum lifts debris that has sunk, using suction rather than a scoop. The PoolMr example lists suction up to 20 GPM for leaves, debris and sand, with a reusable 3D mesh filter made of 180μm material. The YSMJ example lists a roller bristle design and wheels for moving on the pool floor, with suction of 12 GPM in the title, for small leaves, insects, silt and pollen.

A net moves through the surface water and scoops debris into a bag. Both HydraJoy examples list a reinforced plastic frame, elastic nylon mesh at 550 microns, and smooth edges for vinyl, tile and concrete surfaces. The mesh captures leaves, pollen, bugs and dust, with water flowing through while debris stays trapped, according to the listings.

Power, reach and upkeep

Both vacuum examples are cordless and rechargeable. The YSMJ listing states no cords or hoses. The PoolMr listing does not state a charge time, only runtime up to 90 minutes. The YSMJ bullets state about 2 hours to charge, with about 2 hours of use after a full charge, which differs from its title runtime.

No charging is stated for either net listing, since neither lists a motor or battery, and upkeep is rinsing the net bag with water and shaking off debris. The PoolMr vacuum filter is washable and reusable, and its listing says to keep the unit dry after use. The YSMJ listing says to submerge the water outlet of the machine during use.

Gear for each route

These are scored on the Chill Score, which weighs performance, build and value most, with safety where it applies, and warranty. None states a warranty term, so warranty is zero for all, and none states a certification, so safety is zero for all.

Scores run from 9.2 to 9.8: each product’s point total is placed on that range, so more points always means a higher score.

Choose a hot tub vacuum if

• You need to lift sunken debris of the kind the vacuum listings state, such as sand on the PoolMr example or silt and insects on the YSMJ example.
• You want cordless movement without hoses or cords.
• You want a washable filter bag, as stated on the PoolMr example.
• You need extension poles for deeper water, as stated on the PoolMr example.

Choose a skimmer net if

• You need to scoop floating leaves, bugs and dust from the surface.
• You want a simple hand tool that rinses clean.
• You want smooth edges for vinyl, tile or concrete surfaces.
• You want a fine mesh for pollen and dust as well as leaves.

Check Your Space First

• Measure tub depth against vacuum reach, using the PoolMr example figures of minimum depth 0.6 feet and maximum depth 7.55 feet with poles.
• Check that a cordless vacuum can be kept dry after use, as the PoolMr listing states.
• Check pole length for the net picked, since HydraJoy listings state a pole connection but no pole length.
• Plan storage for a vacuum with poles and a storage bag, as the PoolMr listing states a storage bag is included.

Common questions

Can a cordless vacuum clean a hot tub floor?

Both vacuum examples list hot tubs among their uses, with suction for sunken debris. The PoolMr example lists leaves, debris and sand, and the YSMJ example lists wheels for moving on the pool floor. Check the listed depth range against the tub before ordering.

Does a skimmer net clean sunken debris?

HydraJoy listings describe scooping and surface cleaning, with a mesh bag that traps debris as water flows through. They do not state powered suction from the floor. For sunken debris, the vacuum examples list suction and floor movement instead.

How long does a cordless vacuum run?

The PoolMr example states runtime up to 90 minutes. The YSMJ title states 90 minutes, while its bullets state about 2 hours of use after a full charge, so that listing leaves runtime unclear. Check the listing for the vacuum picked, since the two vacuum examples do not agree on a single runtime figure.

Do I need a pole for a skimmer net?

HydraJoy titles state the net comes with a pole, and the bullets describe a connection point between net and pole. Pole length is not stated in either HydraJoy listing. Check the listed net size of 10.4 x 0.93 x 14.2 inches against the tub before ordering.

Back to all hot tub reviews.