Silonn vs Frigidaire Nugget Ice Maker: Which One Should You Buy?

Silonn vs frigidaire nugget ice maker at a glance

Both listings describe chewable nugget ice for drinks: the Silonn listing names sodas, cocktails and iced coffee, and the Frigidaire listing names restaurant-style sonic ice that floats in a beverage. The split is output against speed: the Frigidaire example states up to 44 lb of ice daily and a 3.97 lbs basket, while the Silonn example states 33 lb per 24 hours, first ice in 6 minutes and stated dimensions of 8.9 in L x 11.3 in D x 12.9 in H, against 14.6 in x 10.0 in x 16.75 in for the Frigidaire example. Noise is stated only for the Silonn example at 40dB, and basket capacity is stated only for the Frigidaire example, so those points stay unranked.

Daily output and first ice

Daily output separates the two examples clearly: the Frigidaire example states up to 44 lb of ice daily, against 33 lb per 24 hours for the Silonn example. First ice runs the other way: the Silonn example states nugget ice in 6 minutes, while the Frigidaire example states first nuggets in 10-15 minutes. Neither figure decides the whole comparison: a household that runs through ice all day leans on daily output, while a household that wants ice soon after switching on leans on first ice.

Size, basket and controls

The Frigidaire example measures 14.6 in x 10.0 in x 16.75 in in the spec table, and the listing says it fits under cabinets. The Silonn example measures 8.9 in L x 11.3 in D x 12.9 in H in the bullets, and the listing says it fits any countertop. Basket capacity is stated only on the Frigidaire side at 3.97 lbs; the Silonn listing describes a detachable basket with a handle but states no capacity figure, so basket size cannot be ranked. Controls differ in style: the Silonn example uses an ICE button with indicator lights for empty water and a full basket, while the Frigidaire example uses a touch panel with drawer access and a viewing window for checking ice levels.

Cleaning and upkeep

Both listings state self-cleaning: the Silonn example has a self-cleaning function, and the Frigidaire example has automated self-cleaning at the press of a button. The Silonn listing adds a detachable top for manual descale or deep-clean access, while the Frigidaire listing adds an ice scoop and drip tray. Water handling is manual on both examples: the Silonn listing says to add water and press ICE, and the Frigidaire listing states no water hookup is needed, just plug in and fill the reservoir.

These are scored on the Chill Score, which weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty as published on the How We Review page. Neither listing states a UL or ETL listing, so both score 0 for safety. Both listings state a 1 year warranty term, so both score on warranty.

Scores run from 9.2 to 9.8: each product’s point total is placed on that range, so more points always means a higher score. Safety counts only for powered gear or where the listing states safety features; where it does not apply, the score is taken over the remaining 90 points.

Choose the Silonn example if

• You want first ice in 6 minutes rather than 10-15 minutes.
• You want a stated 40dB operation figure on the listing.
• You want a detachable basket with a handle for carrying ice.
• You want a smaller stated height at 12.9 in H.

Choose the Frigidaire example if

• You want up to 44 lb of ice per day rather than 33 lb per 24 hours.
• You want a stated basket capacity at 3.97 lbs.
• You want a touch panel with drawer access and a viewing window.
• You want an ice scoop and drip tray included in the listing.

Check Your Space First

• Counter space: the Silonn example states 8.9 in L x 11.3 in D x 12.9 in H, and the Frigidaire example states 14.6 in x 10.0 in x 16.75 in; the Frigidaire listing says it fits under cabinets, so check the under-cabinet clearance against its 16.75 in height before ordering.
• Water: both examples fill manually; the Frigidaire listing states no water hookup is needed, and the Silonn listing says to add water and press ICE.
• Storage: the Frigidaire example states a 3.97 lbs basket; the Silonn listing states no basket capacity figure, only a detachable basket with a handle.
• Cleaning access: the Silonn example has a detachable top for manual descale or deep-clean, and both examples state self-cleaning.

Common questions

Which nugget ice maker makes ice faster?

The Silonn example states first ice in 6 minutes, against 10-15 minutes for the Frigidaire example. Faster first ice is not the same as higher daily output: the Frigidaire example states up to 44 lb per day, against 33 lb per 24 hours for the Silonn example.

Which is quieter?

The listings do not say. The Silonn listing states 40dB operation, while the Frigidaire listing states no noise figure, so quietness cannot be ranked from these listings.

Do these ice makers need a water hookup?

The Frigidaire listing states no water hookup is needed: plug in and fill the reservoir. The Silonn listing describes adding water and pressing ICE, which reads as manual filling, but unlike the Frigidaire listing it does not state that no hookup is needed.

What warranty does each listing state?

The Silonn listing states a 1 year manufacturer warranty, and the Frigidaire listing states a 1 year limited warranty. The term length matches; only the wording differs.

Which fits a smaller counter?

It depends on which dimension is tight: the Silonn example is shorter in height at 12.9 in H, against 16.75 in for the Frigidaire example, while the Frigidaire example’s other stated figures are 14.6 in and 10.0 in, against 8.9 in L and 11.3 in D for the Silonn example. The Frigidaire listing says it fits under cabinets, so check the tight dimension before ordering.

Back to all cold plunge reviews.